Hard-boiled Dreams of the World » Blog Archive » Illegal Immigration Part 2: Border Patrol

Illegal Immigration Part 2: Border Patrol

This is part 2 of a series. Read part 1: A Deluge of Illegal Facts.

USA and Tijuana Border The United States-Mexico border runs for 2000 miles from the Pacific Ocean to the Gulf of Mexico. There are 250 million legal crossings each year, making it the busiest international land border in the world. Not counted in that statistic are more than 500,000 illegal crossings each year.

The Border Fence

In 2006, Congress and the Bush administration approved 700 miles of new fencing on the border, along with a $1.2 billion down payment. But people who know the border know this: while a fence may slow down the illegal traffic, it won’t stop it.

And the price to American taxpayers (and their grandchildren) is huge.

The new fence will actually be a double fence in many areas, separated by a cleared 100 yard border zone. And, according to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, it will cost $1.2 million per mile to build. Figuring in maintenance costs for 25 years, the pricetag jumps to between $16 million and $70 million per mile. To adequately fence the entire 2000 miles? That comes to a bare minimum of $32 billion, thank you very much.

Border Tunnels

Border Tunnel While you’re pondering that shiny new fence, and hoping that it’s never used to keep Americans in instead of keeping foreigners out, think about this: As the fence goes up, illegal traffic goes down — not only down in numbers, but down as in “underground.”

During this decade, over 20 tunnels have been discovered beneath the existing fence in San Diego. One such tunnel was almost a half mile long and ran to a depth of 60 feet. The 4 by 6 foot tunnel, which had a concrete floor and electricity, began near the Tijuana airport and ended beneath a loose tile floor in a modern U.S. warehouse.

The cost to seal this tunnel, and another one like it? $500,000 in engineering and labor costs. And as soon as contractors seal a tunnel, somewhere in the night a section of fence is being destroyed with blow torches and hacksaws…

Border Field State Park

The US-Mexico border crawls out of the Pacific Ocean at Border Field State Park, which splits the beach between Tijuana and San Diego. The location of the border was set by a joint Mexican and American survey group after the Mexican-American War ended in 1848. After taking 500,000 acres from Mexico (40% of its territory), the US gave Mexico $15 million so there wouldn’t be any hard feelings.

In 1851, the U.S. erected a marble obelisk and a park at the site to mark the southwestern corner of our nation, and to proclaim our friendship with Mexico. Later, to further celebrate our friendship, a border fence was erected right over the top of the friendship monument.

Today, the beach section of the fence is frequently damaged by storms. People freely walk through to test the waters on the U.S. side of the beach, or to buy roasted corn and Coca-colas from venders near the Tijuana bullring. As long as visitors don’t wander too far or stay too long, the ever-present Border Patrol usually doesn’t get involved.

The Sonora Desert

East of San Diego and into Arizona, the border runs through the Sonora Desert and mountain country.

As bigger fences are erected near the border’s high-traffic areas, more and more illegal immigrants risk crossing the border in Sonora. There, they not only have to cross the international border; they have to also cross one of the largest and harshest deserts in North America. With temperatures climbing to 120 degrees in the summer, many immigrants try to make the multiple-day journey on foot carrying just a gallon of water. As a result, hundreds of immigrants die from heat stroke and dehydration each year.

Sonora Desert Immigration Litter Heaps and heaps of discarded trash are another result of the desert’s increased traffic.

Hired guides, known as “coyotes”, lead groups of as many as 100 illegal immigrants to areas known as “lay up” sites. Once there, the immigrants change clothes and discard travel items before being picked up by helpers in vans and trucks who shuttle them to Tucson and other cities. Many lay up sites are located in once-pristine wildlife refuges…refuges which are now carpeted with thousands of backpacks, water bottles, sweaters, razors, cell phones, rope, batteries, food containers, and human waste.

In the Tucson sector of Arizona alone, agents apprehend 1,500 illegal immigrants each day. That many people discard a lot of garbage. Last year, the Arizona Bureau of Land Management spent nearly $1 million to clean up over a million pounds of trash. And that’s only a fraction of what gets left behind each year.

Nogales, Arizona

Nogales Border As the border approaches Nogales, Arizona, the dilapidated barbed wire fence becomes a metal wall again. The fence winds through town, along streets and backyards.

On any given night, border crossers trigger security sensors along the fence. The sensors alert border agents who employ night-vision video cameras, flashlights, and bicycles in an endless effort to stem the wave of illegal immigrants that surges through town each night.

New Mexico, Chihuahua, and Drugs

From Arizona, the border runs into New Mexico, which shares an 180 mile boundary with the Mexican state of Chihuahua.

Along this border, the city of Columbus, New Mexico, is just two miles away from Palomas, Mexico. Because of recent drug-related violence, parents are keeping their children out of school, and deputies have begun routinely carrying assault rifles.

Cocaine is the source of the violence between drug cartels in Mexico. And, while Mexico does little to stem the northward flow of illegal cocaine traffic, the United States does little to stop the southward flow of guns from the U.S. that end up in the hands of Mexican drug cartels and gangs.

Surpisingly, one of the biggest customers of Mexican drugs aren’t criminals: the economy of Palomas is heavily dependant on U.S. senior citizens who cross the border for cheap medication and dental work.

Trouble in Texas

The state with the longest Mexican border is Texas. And, as is befitting the largest border state, Texas has the most corruption cases against border guards for accepting bribes, offering aid, and profitting from a $5 billion human smuggling business.

Texas also has the most outspoken opposition to the new fence construction.

For example, there’s the case of Eloisa Tamez:

Tamez owns three acres of land along the Texas-Mexico border where the Department of Homeland Security would like to build a border fence. The property is a remnant of a 12,000-acre grant from Spain to her family in 1767, before the United States even existed.

And then there’s the case of the fence at the University of Texas at Brownsville, which might separate the university from its golf course, and leave the outfield of its baseball park amutated.

The Department of Homeland Security is also facing more border fence suits filed by the city of El Paso, a local Indian tribe, two West Texas water improvement districts, and several environmental groups.

The End of the Border

US and Mexico Border Marker At the Gulf of Mexico near Brownsville, the border once again runs into an ocean. And what can now be said?

Even people who have lived on the border their whole life will tell you it’s hard to define. A marble obelisk — or even a hundred yard no man’s land between two chain link fences — doesn’t do the job. One country doesn’t run right up to the edge of another country and stop; the two bleed into each other, and even with a fence in place, both societies mix, creating a unique cultural region that extends for hundreds of miles on either side of the survey line.

And fences? Fences work, and they don’t work too. As for stopping illegal immigration, a bigger fence is only a speedbump. But speedbumps do have their place. Whether a border fence has its place may take years to discover.

Coming soon: Illegal Immigration Part 3: Chasing Hope.

Related Articles

You and Which Pseudo Historical Figure?
Illegal Immigration Part 1: A Deluge of Illegal Facts
I Met the Walrus
Bush on the Fence
Senator Inhofe’s Shocking Freudian Slip

This entry was posted on Tuesday, June 10th, 2008 at 12:21 am and is filed under Politics. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.

9 Responses to “Illegal Immigration Part 2: Border Patrol”

zeezil says:

Tuesday, June 10, 2008 at 7:34 am

Fences Work:

They just have to be engineered and properly constructed. Consider 14-mile double-layer fence between San Diego and Tijuana, Mexico. Its benefits in stopping illegal entry into the U.S. were immediate and long lasting. According to a 2005 Congressional Research Service report illegal alien apprehensions along the fence region dropped from 202,000 in 1992 to 9,000 in 2004, a reduction greater than 95%.

Besides, if fences don’t work then why is there one around the White House

Reply
Lynne says:

Tuesday, June 10, 2008 at 1:59 pm

Fences certainly work to disrupt the migratory patterns of wildlife. Other than that, the only real accomplishment of a fence is to further the illusion that “us” is different from “them”.

Reply
JoeC says:

Tuesday, June 10, 2008 at 7:46 pm

There’s definitely a good balance between an overbearing Berlin Wall type of fence and the lack of any boundary at all. I can see the benefit of the fence in San Diego where, without a “speed bump,” waves of humanity would flow back and forth each day and just create too much chaos. But, in the outlying rural areas, I think a few helicopters with infrared scopes is much more cost effective and less damaging to the environment than super fences manned with soldiers and assault weapons. Balance, in everything, is king.

Reply
pelmo says:

Wednesday, June 11, 2008 at 6:53 am

As long as these waves of immigrants keep the profits high, there will be no effort to keep them out. We all know as long as corporations profit, the hell with all the harm it may cause. The bottom line is king and trumps everything else.

Reply
uk immigration says:

Wednesday, June 11, 2008 at 7:42 am

A fence will not work and whilst the US taxpayer would eventually have to pay for it, in the short term the US will have to borrow more money from China to fund it.
Anybody naive enough to think a fence will work should look up ‘Maginot Line’…
When you consider how much the Bush administration has wasted/paid itself on the war in Iraq it amazes me that there are still people like zeezil who think the illegal immigrants are stealing from him/her; I’ve got news for you it’s not the immigrants - it’s your government.

Reply
Dusty says:

Thursday, June 12, 2008 at 7:18 pm

No jobs will keep the great unwashed masses from coming to the US. Its a no-friggin-brainer and I am tired of saying it.

AZ recently enacted a law that will penalize the company’s and corporations that hire illegal immigrants..and the sliding scale gets worse each time they are busted..up and including losing their right to have a business operating in AZ. The law was fought in the courts and the courts have so far upheld AZ’s right to go after the companies.

Sadly, the majority of illegals do not come in by walking over that god-forsaken border..its a known fact and I am tired of repeating that also. So building this worthless expensive boondoggle won’t do anything except make the damn contractor rich. Just like the camera’s the feds paid for that don’t work along the border..that company was paid in full and they don’t fucking work at all.

There are so many wrong assumptions out there about illegal immigrants it makes me sick.

Reply
JoeC says:

Friday, June 13, 2008 at 10:00 am

Dusty’s right…a big part of the illegal immigrant population came to the U.S. legally, but then overstayed their visas. A super-duper fence won’t help with that problem.

Reply
Xman says:

Saturday, June 21, 2008 at 10:53 am

I have a new set of rules I made on my PH adjusting vacation.
So, I’m not going to let anyone seperate me from the common humanity I feel for all peoples.

Maybe this is an issue we need to deal with.
But I think we know a few things:

It would be simple and without any cost to get all illegals to leave if our government really wanted them to.
Just fine AND put in jail anyone/employer who hires an illegal. Without work, illegals could not eat, pay rent, drive cars. They would take themselves home without any cost to us.

We don’t need a fence, since no ne would come over if they couldn’t work.

I think we know the management arm of the corporations (Congress) doesn’t want to do anything to stop the flow. Business wants the cheap labor and they don’t want the cheap labor to have any of the costly protections or benefits Americans have.

I think we know what great techniques demonizing and dividing are. They lead to actions that take us away from reasonable discussion and toward antagonism and war.

I’m not a Christian, but Christ is reputed to have advised that we love our enemies. I think it is logical to assume that to get to “love”, we must first seek to understand and respect.

Reply
JoeC says:

Tuesday, June 24, 2008 at 4:50 pm

Good government (and leadership in general) is about giving people good incentives to do the right thing. From the war on terrorism to the war in Iraq to most everything the current administration has touched, they’ve been “leading” with billion-dollar big sticks and waterboards, when the right incentives would work much better at alleviating national problems. And of course, they have displayed a huge lack of respect for many.

Reply

Illegal Immigration Part 2: Border Patrol

The Border Fence

Border Tunnels

Border Field State Park

The Sonora Desert

Nogales, Arizona

New Mexico, Chihuahua, and Drugs

Trouble in Texas

The End of the Border

9 Responses to “Illegal Immigration Part 2: Border Patrol”

Leave a Reply

Search

About

Subscribe

Recent Comments

Most Popular Posts

Recent Posts

Categories

Contact